You found our guide to employee time theft and how to spot and prevent it.
Employee time theft describes instances where workers get compensation for time they did not spend working. Examples include buddy punching, excessive breaks, or personal time. The purpose of preventing employee time theft is to boost productivity and cut the company’s losses.
These tips are related to employee monitoring software, employee scheduling software, and task management software and can be used to manage remote teams.
This article contains:
- what is employee time theft
- examples of time theft
- how to spot employee time theft
- how to prevent employee time theft
- employee time theft punishment best practices
Let’s get started!
What is employee time theft?
Employee time theft refers to the practice of employees intentionally misrepresenting the hours they have worked to receive pay for time they did not actually spend on the job. This theft can occur in various ways, such as employees clocking in for their colleagues, inflating the number of hours worked, taking extended breaks beyond the allotted time, or leaving work early while reporting full hours. Essentially, time theft involves any deliberate attempt to manipulate time records for personal gain.
Time theft can have significant negative consequences for businesses. Companies may experience financial losses due to paying wages for unproductive hours. Additionally, employees who engage in time theft are not fully engaged in their work responsibilities. This disengagement can result in missed deadlines, incomplete projects, and a general decline in overall team performance. Moreover, time theft can create a sense of unfairness and resentment among employees who are honest about their work hours, which can harm team morale and workplace culture.
To prevent and address employee time theft, organizations should implement effective time-tracking systems and establish clear policies regarding attendance and time reporting. Regular monitoring and audits of time records can help identify inconsistencies or suspicious patterns. Communication plays a vital role, as educating employees about the importance of accurate timekeeping and the consequences of time theft can act as a deterrent. By fostering a culture of transparency, accountability, and fairness, businesses can mitigate the negative impacts of time theft and promote a more productive work environment.
Examples of time theft
Time theft is not limited to one sector. Employees who steal time from their employers may resort to elaborate plots to avoid doing their jobs. Therefore, you must know how to spot employee time theft to curb the situation.
1. Falsifying Time Cards
Falsifying time cards happens when employees intentionally manipulate the information recorded on their timekeeping documents. This process could involve inaccurately inflating the number of hours they have worked, clocking in earlier or clocking out later than their actual arrival or departure times, or even pretending to be present when they were actually absent. Such actions distort the accuracy of attendance records and working hours, potentially leading to unjustified compensation. This behavior leads to financial losses for the company and undermines the trust and fairness within the workplace environment.
2. Buddy Punching
Buddy punching occurs when an employee punches in or out on the time clock for a colleague, usually when that individual is not present. This act distorts the true record of an employee’s attendance, as it falsely indicates their presence when they were not working. Thus, companies may incorrectly pay for hours not actually worked, which disrupts the integrity of attendance tracking systems. Buddy punching affects payroll accuracy and erodes the sense of responsibility and honesty among employees. Additionally, this process challenges the transparency and reliability of the workforce management process.
Get our free team building toolbox
- icebreaker games
- bingo cards
- DIY guides
by teams at FedEx, Amazon, Deloitte and 73,930+ others
3. Unapproved or Extended Breaks
Unapproved or extended breaks refer to instances where employees take breaks that are either longer than allowed or at unapproved times. These actions result in a decrease in actual working hours, leading to decreased productivity and operational efficiency. Extended breaks can disrupt workflow and delay tasks or projects, affecting team collaboration and project timelines. Additionally, the absence of proper break schedules can create a sense of inequity among employees who adhere to the rules, potentially affecting morale and overall workplace harmony.
4. Phone Usage
Excessive personal phone usage during work hours can harm productivity and concentration. Using phones for non-work-related activities diverts employees’ attention away from their tasks, leading to interruptions, decreased output, and lowered quality of work. This behavior can also foster a culture of distraction and disengagement, impacting the overall work environment. Additionally, prolonged phone usage for personal matters may result in wasted time and decreased focus on job responsibilities. This affect contributes to reduced team efficiency and potentially compromises the achievement of business goals.
5. Personal Pursuits
Employees can steal time by working on personal projects during work hours. Some workers may not see anything wrong with engaging in personal activities during business time. These employees may run side hustles or use work hours to do personal tasks. Colleagues often waste time during work hours chatting and eating lunch together. Such employees might even decide to take a nap during the day. Employees who spend their days at a computer may use that time to pay bills online, while those who work from home might do errands like grocery shopping and banking during work hours.
6. Internet Activities
Internet use during working hours is a major distraction, especially for those workers whose jobs require them to spend most of their time seated in front of a computer screen. Workers who engage in this activity often waste hours each week on personal social media or other sites unrelated to their jobs.
The cost of switching between tasks is high, as you are losing money and valuable time by being distracted. In addition, a worker’s momentum and attention diminish somewhat every time they switch tasks, like going online from a work tool to a personal site. It takes a few minutes for an employee’s brain to completely shift concentration back to work after they have been distracted by a site like Facebook.
You are essentially struck twice as an employer by this kind of theft. First, when workers use the internet for personal reasons during work hours, and again when they must readjust their attention to return to their original tasks.
7. Disappearing from Work
Employees may disappear without a trace in certain workplaces, such as those with vast open floor plans or outdoor work locations where supervisors are constantly on the move. It may be some time before detecting this theft of company time, but these disappearances will have a major effect on productivity.
Organizations with spacious offices and perks like cafeterias and gyms are more likely to have this problem. There has been a widespread shift to remote work since the COVID-19 epidemic. Whether it is household tasks, errands, or recreational pursuits, workers may easily become sidetracked when they can work remotely.
8. Rounding Time Off
Time and attendance software may round the time differently. While some systems may round time to the nearest 15 minutes, others may only round every three minutes. When an employee is concerned that they will not be able to meet their daily hour requirements, they may intentionally delay clocking off for a few minutes before doing so to try to game the system. In most cases, the U.S. Department of Labor allows employers to make reasonable time-rounding changes for workers.
9. Sleeping at Work
Sleeping at work involves employees intentionally dozing off during designated work hours. This practice demonstrates a disregard for job responsibilities and results in a halt in productivity. Employees who sleep at work neglect their duties, leading to missed deadlines, incomplete tasks, and an overall decline in work quality. This behavior can also foster negative perceptions among colleagues who witness or are affected, potentially leading to resentment and a toxic work atmosphere. Ultimately, sleeping at work disrupts the work environment, undermines team cohesion, and poorly reflects an employee’s professionalism and commitment.
How to prevent employee time theft
Besides knowing how employees steal time, managers should know how to prevent the situation. The following are some suggestions for avoiding time theft at your company.
1. Set Clear Expectations
When employees are unsure about their roles and responsibilities, it can lead to confusion and potentially create opportunities for time theft. Setting clear expectations involves providing employees with detailed job descriptions and outlining specific tasks, projects, and goals. Clearly define work hours, break times, and any rules related to time tracking. When employees have a comprehensive understanding of what you expect of them, they are more likely to manage their time effectively and honestly.
2. Hold Regular Performance Reviews
Regular performance reviews serve as an opportunity for managers and employees to discuss progress, achievements, and areas for improvement. These discussions should include conversations about time management, productivity, and any concerns about time theft. By addressing these topics openly, managers can provide guidance and support. Additionally, employees can express any challenges they might face that could contribute to time theft. These reviews also reinforce the importance of accurate timekeeping and foster a sense of accountability.
3. Create Anonymous Reporting Channels
Implementing anonymous reporting channels, such as a dedicated email address or an online portal, allows employees to report suspicions of time theft or other misconduct without revealing their identities. This technique encourages employees to come forward with concerns they might otherwise hesitate to share due to fear of retaliation. Anonymous reporting channels help maintain a culture of honesty and integrity while allowing the organization to address potential issues promptly.
4. Rotate Tasks
Monotony and routine can contribute to employee disengagement, which may result in time theft as a way to break the monotony. By regularly rotating tasks or providing opportunities for employees to work on different projects, you keep their work experience fresh and engaging. This step can lead to increased motivation and reduced temptation to engage in time theft to escape the boredom associated with repetitive tasks.
5. Lead by Example
Managers and leaders play a crucial role in shaping workplace behavior. When managers consistently demonstrate punctuality, honesty, and adherence to time-tracking policies, they set a positive example for their teams. Conversely, if leaders disregard time management rules, then it sends a message that these rules are not important. Leading by example reinforces the value of accurate timekeeping and creates a culture of responsibility and accountability throughout the organization.
6. Adopt a Time-Tracking Software
One effective method to avoid time theft is to use time clock software. Such tools are significantly more difficult to manipulate than paper logs, Excel time trackers, and punch clocks.
By establishing time rules, you can reduce time misreporting of hours with time clock software. For example, you can stop early check-in or request that workers use their mobile app features to clock back in after breaks.
Additionally, GPS and geofencing rules allow you to monitor where your remote workers are at all times. You may use the software to ensure that employees only clock in at the designated location or to determine exactly where an employee who keeps claiming to be “caught in traffic” truly is spending their time.
While certain time clock software still allows for buddy punching, more sophisticated techniques like biometrics or time clocks that need accompanying images may make this time theft difficult, if not impossible.
In addition to helping you finish projects on schedule, many time-tracking applications also allow you to cut down on time spent on non-work-related activities or websites. For example, certain time-tracking software requires workers to log every minute they spend on a project. You can also monitor employees’ online behavior with screenshots and URL reports. These time clock solutions will help you avoid losing money to time theft and will also provide you with reliable, real-time data on employee output, attendance, and expenditures.
7. Keep An Eye Out for Signs of Disengagement
It is easy to spot employees who steal time from the employer or fail to complete their tasks. For example, if an employee suddenly stops answering their work phone or checking their email, this might raise suspicions. However, this case is not conclusive evidence of time stealing. An indication of disengagement could be if an employee often submits assessments late or is less accessible than peers.
Mistakes happen, but when the same ones keep cropping up, it is time to look at why. Managers must keep their remote staff updated on the company’s purpose and roles.
8. Have Meetings Regularly
Holding meetings is the right approach to handling time theft concerns without making open accusations. Employees stay informed and aware of their roles and duties via staff meetings. For instance, employees on your sales team might engage in other endeavors when they are not attending to customers. During the meeting, you can let your workers know what you expect them to do when customers are not around. When everyone in the firm has a voice in conversations and decisions, morale and motivation at work rise.
9. Keep Tabs on Employees
Understanding your staff’s sentiments requires being in the know about their circumstances. Your remote employees have a full plate outside of work as well. Such workers can feel overwhelmed by financial concerns or just exhausted. It is important to keep tabs on employees so you can know how they are doing and hear about any problems. Sometimes, inquiring about their days might help alleviate the loneliness and isolation that some remote employees experience.
10. Build Employee Morale
Content workers often result in satisfied clients. However, mismanaged stress and poor working circumstances can cause low engagement rates. A high turnover rate is indicative of employee engagement issues. There is a direct correlation between widespread time theft and bad morale, which hurts productivity and the bottom line. Many minimum wage workers steal time from their employers because they believe their employers are unfair.
When employees observe their counterparts getting away with time theft, it may hurt morale. Reduced morale and increased turnover go hand in hand.
Workers are more loyal and productive when they feel appreciated. You can set up a system of incentives and awards for staff members. You can award shift workers time off or an additional shift if they do well. You can mitigate employee time theft by fostering an environment where people are open and trustworthy.
Here are ways to increase staff morale.
Employee time theft punishment best practices
Several options exist for dealing with the possibility of time fraud among employees. Having unmistakable evidence at hand is the most critical first step. With tools like time clock software, you may easily spot instances of time theft. Managers can use the proof to give employees an opportunity for restitution. You can file suit against a repeat offender, but doing so will be expensive for your company and probably is not worth it.
The following are steps to take after discovering employee time theft.
1. Incident Documentation
Documenting incidents of time theft is crucial for maintaining accurate records and ensuring fair treatment of all employees. It is important to record details like the date, time, location, description of the incident, individuals involved, and any relevant communication. This documentation serves as evidence if further action is required, and it helps assess patterns of behavior over time. Proper documentation is essential to protect the organization from potential legal disputes.
2. Supervisor and HR Involvement
Involving supervisors and human resources in the handling of time theft cases adds objectivity and consistency to the process. Supervisors can provide insights into the employee’s behavior and work history, while HR can ensure that the chosen course of action aligns with company policies and legal regulations. Having multiple perspectives minimizes biases and ensures that decisions are well-informed and fair.
3. Progressive Discipline
Progressive discipline is an approach to addressing employee misconduct that involves a series of increasingly severe consequences for repeated or escalating offenses. The process typically follows a sequence, such as verbal warning, written warning, suspension, and finally, termination. This approach allows employees to correct their behavior before facing more severe consequences. Progressive discipline is effective in demonstrating a fair and consistent response to time theft as well as providing clear expectations for improvement.
4. Legal Compliance
When implementing consequences for time theft, it is crucial to adhere to relevant labor laws and regulations. Different jurisdictions may have specific requirements regarding disciplinary procedures, termination, and employee rights. Failing to comply with legal standards can lead to legal disputes and reputational damage for the organization. Be sure that your actions align with applicable laws to prevent legal complications.
5. Termination in Severe Cases
Termination is a last-resort consequence for severe or repeated time theft cases that have not been fixed through progressive discipline. Before considering termination, thoroughly assess the situation and consult with HR and legal advisors. Be sure that you document the time theft incidents well and that the decision to terminate is consistent with company policies and employment agreements. Termination should always be handled respectfully and professionally, considering the impact on both the individual employee and the organization.
Conclusion
Productivity suffers due to employee time theft. This situation will affect your company due to client complaints. It is vital to use strategies that boost productivity in the workplace. Although it may appear more challenging to manage, you can effectively monitor and motivate workers to achieve higher output levels. You should note that building a culture of openness, honesty, and trust helps deter time theft.
Also, check out other resources on the best time tracking software, time management strategies for work, and time management books.
